After a strong recovery from April’s tariff-induced crash, the ASX 200 is once again trading near record highs. But are these gains sustainable, or is the market showing signs of a bubble? This analysis explores the seven major warning signals investors should watch closely before deciding their next move.
After recovering from April's tariff-induced crash, the S&P/ASX 200 is once again trading near record highs. Yet beneath the surface, the market looks stretched. Current estimates place the index at around 20.8 times earnings, well above its long-term average of roughly 16–17 times. So are we headed for trouble, or is everything fine?
Here are seven warning signs that suggest the ASX may be overheating, along with the counterarguments that keep investors optimistic.
The ASX is trading at around 20.8 times earnings, which is elevated compared to its long-term average range of 14.8–19.2 times. This suggests investors are pricing in strong future growth, which may or may not materialise.
What's concerning is the disconnect between stock prices and company fundamentals. While revenues have grown modestly, profit margins have come under pressure in several sectors, and earnings growth has been uneven. Despite this, investors continue to pay premium prices, particularly in sectors like technology, where valuations remain high relative to expected earnings.
Instantly access our exclusive report and see which stocks our analysts are backing for growth this year.
 |
|
Download now to access expert research from ASRW analysts and strengthen your investment strategy.
Recent market behaviour suggests smart money may be repositioning. After an impressive run that saw banks like Westpac and Commonwealth Bank climb around 40% throughout 2024, the financial sector now looks fully priced. Many analysts believe there's not much room left for gains.
At the same time, mining stocks that took a beating in 2024- BHP down 20%, lithium plays like Pilbara Minerals falling over 40%- are starting to look attractive again. When investors begin shifting from expensive sectors into cheaper alternatives, it's often an early warning sign that the broader market could be headed for a correction.
How quickly can things change? In late October, materials stocks dropped over 7% in a single day, with financials falling more than 7% as well. When valuations get stretched, sentiment can turn on a dime.
Markets have short memories, but April's 6.5% single-day plunge, the worst since March 2020, should serve as a sobering reminder of how quickly conditions can deteriorate. The ASX 200 fell from a February record high, erasing what was once a 4.3% year-to-date gain and leaving the index down 12% for the year before eventually recovering.
That crash was triggered by escalating trade tensions and tariff announcements, demonstrating how vulnerable expensive markets are to unexpected shocks. The recovery since then has been impressive, but it's also pushed valuations back into dangerous territory.
The ASX remains heavily weighted toward banks and miners, which can amplify volatility. For example, Commonwealth Bank has recently traded around $115–120 per share, reflecting strong investor confidence. However, when a handful of large-cap stocks drive most of the index’s gains, it can mask broader market weakness and create fragility. If sentiment turns on these leaders, the entire index could be vulnerable.
International markets are flashing similar warning signs. In the US, valuation metrics like the Shiller P/E ratio are well above historical averages, though not uniformly higher than every pre-crash level since 1929. Even more concerning is the explosion of leveraged investment products, which have surged 40% in just one year to record levels. This suggests that everyday investors are taking on excessive risk at exactly the wrong time. History shows that when borrowing to invest becomes this popular and widespread, market peaks usually aren't far behind.
Here's the fundamental problem: stock prices keep rising while corporate earnings are actually falling. Over the past three years, company profits have dropped 11% annually, yet the market keeps climbing higher. We've seen this pattern before, during Japan's late-1980s bubble and the dot-com crash. Eventually, reality catches up. Stock prices must align with actual business performance, one way or another.
This might be the most dangerous sign of all. The rapid recovery from April's crash has reinforced the belief that dips should be bought aggressively and that central bank intervention will always prevent major declines. This "this time is different" thinking, the belief that modern markets are too sophisticated or too well-supported to truly crash, is classic bubble psychology. It's the same mentality that has appeared before every major market collapse throughout history.
Before panicking, consider the counterarguments. China's stimulus measures could reignite commodity demand, benefiting Australian miners. The shift towards renewable energy and critical minerals provides structural tailwinds.
Australian banks are financially solid and pay attractive dividends. Fully franked yields around 5-6% look compelling, especially if interest rates fall as expected. Unlike past bubbles built on speculation, today's ASX is dominated by established, cash-generating businesses. Maybe that justifies higher valuations.
Is the ASX in a bubble? The evidence is mixed. Valuations are stretched, and classic warning signs are flashing. April's crash demonstrated how quickly expensive markets correct when sentiment shifts.
But here's the thing, bubbles are only obvious in hindsight. Warning signs can persist for months or even years before anything happens. The market's focus on established, dividend-paying companies provides genuine stability that speculative bubbles lack.
The smart approach? Stay invested, but be defensive. Consider trimming positions in expensive sectors, keep some cash available for opportunities, and focus on quality companies with strong balance sheets and real earnings growth.
Don't abandon shares entirely, but don't assume everything will keep going up either.
Whether this is a bubble or not, these valuations suggest lower returns ahead than we've enjoyed recently. When markets look this expensive, caution is warranted.
If you have any questions or feedback about our service, please feel free to contact us.
3 quality yield income stocks to buy
